Mastering Variance Analysis: Best Practices for Root Cause, Impact, and Corrective Actions
Variance Analysis is a critical component of Earned Value Management Systems (EVMS), providing essential insights into a project's cost and schedule performance. Proper Variance Analysis enhances project oversight, facilitates informed decision-making, and supports the development of effective corrective actions. This article presents best practices for conducting high-quality Variance Analysis based on guidance from the United States Department of Defense (DoD) and U.S. Department of Energy (DOE).
Accountability: The Key to Effective Variance Analysis
Leadership and Key Stakeholder Responsibility
Effective Variance Analysis requires strong leadership buy-in and stakeholder engagement to ensure project objectives are met. Leadership must foster a culture where Variance Analysis is prioritized, providing the necessary resources, training, and support to project teams. Stakeholders, including project sponsors and functional leads, should be actively involved in the review and decision-making processes, ensuring alignment with organizational goals. Analysts play a pivotal role in supporting Control Account Managers (CAMs) by providing accurate data analysis, insights, and recommendations to facilitate informed decisions.
CAM Responsibility
CAMs play the most critical role in Variance Analysis as they are the owners of CAs and bear the ultimate responsibility for project performance within their assigned scope. CAMs must take full ownership of variances, providing comprehensive, detailed, and accurate variance explanations that thoroughly address root causes, impacts, and corrective actions. They are accountable for tracking performance metrics such as cost and schedule performance indices, driving corrective measures, and ensuring their effectiveness. CAMs must also foster a culture of accountability within their teams, working closely with analysts and leadership to ensure data integrity and alignment with project objectives. Regular engagement with project teams, proactive risk identification, and timely communication with stakeholders are essential for maintaining project performance within established baselines.
Key Elements of a Variance Analysis Report (VAR)
A robust VAR should comprehensively address the following key elements:
🔴 Root Cause Analysis
✅ Identify the underlying factors driving the variance, distinguishing between cost and schedule variances.
✅ Use the "5 Whys" and/or other root cause analysis techniques to uncover the true cause.
✅ Consider influences such as labor inefficiencies, material price fluctuations, scope changes, and technical challenges.
✅ Identify whether issues are recurring (systemic) or non-recurring (isolated) to ensure accurate root cause analysis and prevent misleading performance trends.
🟡 Impact Assessment
✅ Evaluate cost, schedule, and technical performance metrics.
✅ Identify critical milestones and dependencies that are affected by the variance.
✅ Assess workforce availability, resource allocation, and productivity impacts.
✅ Consider potential changes to the CA baseline and their implications on future performance.
✅ Ensure that all identified impacts are well-documented and traceable to supporting data sources.
🟢 Recoverability Analysis
✅ Assess whether the variance can be recovered within the control account baseline.
✅ Differentiate between temporary and permanent impacts.
✅ Forecast potential risks and required mitigation strategies.
✅ Evaluate feasibility of recovery using established guidelines.
✅ Align corrective actions with Estimate at Completion (EAC) projections.
✅ Validate mitigation plans using Earned Value Management (EVM) metrics such as CPI, SPI, and TCPI.
🔵 Corrective Action Plan
✅ Define specific, measurable actions to address the identified root cause.
✅ Set deadlines and track progress.
✅ Assign responsibilities for executing corrective actions.
✅ Ensure closed-loop corrective action processes to resolve issues and prevent recurrence.
✅ Hold CAMs accountable for monitoring and reporting corrective actions.
✅ Maintain a corrective action tracking log to ensure visibility and accountability.
Ensuring High-Quality Variance Analysis Reports
High-quality Variance Analysis reports should follow a consistent format, expressing impacts in measurable terms such as $K and avoiding mixing units like hours and quantities. Language should be clear and understandable, with uncommon acronyms spelled out for clarity. The analysis should avoid generic statements such as "within threshold" and instead provide specific details that add value to the report.
✅ Use Quantitative Data: Focus on measurable and objective insights.
✅ Clarity and Conciseness: Write in clear, jargon-free language to ensure the VAR is easily understood by all stakeholders, not just CAMs.
✅ Consistency: Maintain a standardized format across reports.
✅ Documentation and Traceability: Ensure data sources are referenced appropriately.
✅ Regular Review Cycles: Conduct periodic reviews (e.g., VAR Parties) to reassess variance trends and improve analysis quality.
📚 Reference Documents
The following documents provide authoritative guidance on Variance Analysis and EVMS best practices:
DoD Earned Value Management System Interpretation Guide (EVMSIG)
NDIA IPMD EIA-748 EVMS Intent Guide
DOE Guide 413.3-10A, Earned Value Management System (EVMS)
DOE EVMS Compliance Review Standard Operating Procedure (ECRSOP)
These resources outline the standards and expectations for conducting effective Variance Analysis and ensuring compliance with EVMS requirements.
📢 Conclusion
Effective Variance Analysis is essential for project success, providing early warning signals and enabling proactive management. By following the best practices outlined above and leveraging DoD and DOE guidelines, project teams can ensure their Variance Analysis efforts contribute to informed decision-making and project control excellence.
👉 Need help with Variance Analysis? Let’s talk!
📲 949-351-8896
📧 karlo.menoscal@elixirvms.com
💡 Discover the Alchemy of EVMS Excellence with Elixir Value Management Systems, Inc.!
#EVMS #ProjectManagement #Aerospace #Defense
